هل يكشف الظلّ في شريط مصوّر لكفاح حقيقة انتحار زوجته آمنة؟

كان لافتا لمن يدقّق في الشريط عن الانتحار المفترض لآمنة اسماعيل والمصوّر من قبل زوجها كفاح في الرملة البيضاء، بضع ثوان قد تقود الى حلّ لغز هذه الجريمة.

فبين الثواني الـ40 و الـ46، يظهر على الجدار ظلّ شخص يحمل شيئا بيده، فهل يشكل هذا الامر دليلا يساعد على التأكد ان كانت آمنة انتحرت طوعيا أم لا؟.

عزيزي القارئ، فلنشاهد الفيديو مجددا ولنتوقف عند هذه الثواني

المصدر:
فريق موقع القوات اللبنانية

29 responses to “هل يكشف الظلّ في شريط مصوّر لكفاح حقيقة انتحار زوجته آمنة؟”

  1. Eh mazbout ana ntabahtela abel bas fakarto el rejel jawza w 7emil el cell bi ido so ma fakaret bi hal tari2a

  2. اتمنى ان تأخذ القضية منحى جدي..لان بخل البلد صار ارخص شي الانسان…

  3. J ai remarque que sa réaction après la chute de la femme, n’était pas
    rapide du tout!!! il s est retourne mais normalement sans même courir!!!
    Pour un mari qui criait si fort… son retour montre qu’il n était pas
    du tout paniqué, comme le montrent soit disant ses cris!!! Et je me demande… pourquoi il la filmait??? !!!!!
    Bizarre…

  4. بضعة اسئلة يجب ان تطرح ماذا كان يلبس الزوج في ساعتها ان كان يلبس شورت فهذا هو لأن زاوية التصوير تعكس ظله على الحائط

    ولكن من المرجح انه هو لأن للظل يد في الأسفل اما اليد الأخرى فهي في الأعلى لأنه يحمل هاتف التصوبير ويجب ان لا نتسرع ونحكم من خلال ادلة وحده مكتب المباحث الجنائية بأمكانه كشفها فالرجاء من موقعكم عدم التسرع وعرض ادلة هي من اختصاص الشرطة وليس صحفيين وشكرا

  5. In seconds 38 to 39 we can see the finger covering a bit of the camera.. most phones have their cameras on the upper section.. this tells us that he was holding the phone awkwardly when he was shooting the video..this means that the shadow in seconds 40 and 46 are of the cell phone he used to shoot this…

  6. Fi shakhes teni mawjoud ma3on, w daleel el shakhes el teni 7amel sekkeni b eedo wil eed el tenyi 3am yefta7 feeha el beb wil camera ma3 el shakis el teni la2an sawaret ta7areketo,bi ma3na el 2eed el tenyi fadyi men 3am yefta7 feeha el beb wil cam dallet 3am betsawwer fa akid fi shakis teni, w yalli 3amalo jawza drama…

    • ممكن بس بشك لانن عم بيقولوا انوا عندى مشاكل مع زوجها

  7. I have used final cut editing program to clear the picture little and go over it frame by frame on 44:00 that’s 44 seconds and 0 frame of the video it is clear that he is putting some kind of a weapon on the back side of his short just point youtube player to 0:44 and you can see it clearly.

  8. التليفونات لديها أفضل أنواع الكاميرا ،،، لماذا الصورة ليست واضحة من هاتف الزوج ؟؟؟ أسئلة تطرح ولماذا يسجل الإنتحار

  9. Fi chi mech mazbout ma3am ne2dir nesma3 hiye chou kenit 3am betrede 3leh wet2ello law mnesma3 mazbout chou kenit 3am betrede 3leh kenna mna3ref el ha2i2a deghre bas el wadeh mnl video eno fi chi mkhabba hiye mechikle bayn
    aw ben jawza w emma aw mechekle houwe w yeha le2an nabret sawto mech mazbouta houwe w 3am yehkiya fa ma3am ba3ref halil hal jarime mafi wala khet hedelna el ha2i2a bi id jawza w yalle ken 3am bisawer ma3o yemkin ken 3anjad kheyif 3laya w yemkin ken 3am yedhak w yetmaskhar houwe w yalle ma3o min ma khale tentehir deghre bala matfakir …..

  10. Okkkkmm d2i2a jawza li etela mn wara ntaharet le2an sma3o mnih fi matrah bi ma2ta3 bi t2ello eh eh masil mnih

  11. هو كان عم يصور ليبعد الشبهات عنو، حدا بتكون مرتو عم تنتحر وهو مشغول بالتصوير؟ هو اللي دفعها للإنتحار……

  12. Using audio editor I was able to hear part of what she was saying:
    – Ma ba3ref bas enta betfo2esh (Sec 1.439 to 3.250)
    (The file was cut and edited at second 3.268)
    -Bomde l3a2ed (Sec 4.922 to 5.804)
    – 3endak se2a bi khali (Sec 10.495 to 12.074)
    – 5sara (13.287 to 13.943)
    – Enta elet bel 5otta eno ne7na ra7 ..(7ake mish wadi7).. leh?
    3al senye 19.423 byotla3 sot 7ada ghayrun, wbi e5tisar the audio of the video was edited and different places, example at second 13.490 and 15.766 the tone of the husband changes, + whenever she speaks there is lot of background and when he speaks it is very clear. Anyone familiar with audio editor will come out with same results. I wonder why they still did not arrest the husband until they finish the investigation.

    • Good Job Tony, I have tried to isolate her voice as much as i could, while keeping the real time of the video. This woman was most likely forced to jump – the guy is replying with nonsense just to cover her voice – the sound clip can be found at http://www.filedropper.com/amoula2

  13. is that a man voice ? , and in the end when he is opening the door the naif is showed very well on the wall so no need to be confused 🙂

  14. awal shi dalil l idene houwe zeto dalil idento , ma fi insen bi 7eb marto w shefa 3am tente7er byou2af bi sawir 3an b3id ma bi arib w 2ido sebte houwe w3am bi sawer ,law mar3oub ma bikoun mrakaz w hal2ad cool , also bi fakir bi 7alo ino ma yenden bi mawta? uf ken 3endo wa2et yfakir bi hek wade3? w hayde li bi 2ido li kabo faj2a mbayan bi khyel l7et mano la cell wala camera mbayan mitil sikin….. mhadeda akid ya tente7er ya ye2tela …. wen sawta 7ada seme3 shou 3am bit2oul? WLESH SARAKH ABIL MA TKIB 7ALA ?? sarakh rij3it kabit 7ala … hayda LCODE ye3ne ??????

  15. wa7ad marto 3am tente7er ma bi jarib y2areb 3laya ? we2if 3al beb? w belo ysawir video ta ma ykoun motaham bi mawta ? uf shou hal kizbe ye3ne dalil bara2to houwe dalil idento , shoufo ido shou sebte houwe w3am bi sawir ma32oul wa7ad monhar wkheyif 3a marto ma bterjof ido? also fi bi ido shi kabo aw khtafa ma ba3rif kif faj2a , wlesh sarakh abel ma tkeb 7ala? shou hayda code ino sar lwa2et ta tkibe 7alik? hayda wa7ad mejrim w moumasil bas feshil

  16. Honestly, ever since I watched it the first time I can’t stop thinking about it. I can’t stop thinking how everyone is blaming the man, and making conclusions when no one really knows what happened. here are my thoughts about it all.

    1. did you notice how he was filming so steady all the time, but when he moved the camera downwards a bit, that’s when she started making the move to jump. maybe he was trying to get closer and help, that’s why she decided to jump.

    2. the “tool” that shows in the shadow (00:44s) is not something solid, so it couldn’t be a knife or a gun. if you go through the video frame by frame (not just pause it), you’ll see that whatever is in his hand was swinging back and forth. go back a few seconds, when he was trying to stand up, you’ll see that on (00:37s) he was grabbing his keychain, which is in the form of a black string/leather. he grabs the keys in his hand and it’s the leather of the keychain that swings back and forth.

    3. for those saying that there was a third person, how in the world there’s going to be a third person if that person doesn’t even have a shadow on the wall? the guy had the keychain in one hand, the cellphone/camera in the other and that’s that. who opened the door for him? it’s a balcony door, it stays open 95% of the time.

    4. about his voice being clear and loud, and hers isn’t. consider this:

    – she’s sitting a few meters away from him.

    – he’s holding the cellphone. so his mouth is practically centimeters away from the microphone.

    – he’s freaking out, so his voice pretty loud.

    – she’s very calm and not even trying to raise her voice. (she was even brushing her hair with her hands)

    5. some say he’s replying with nonsense and changing tones. well, let’s see those people in that same situation and try to speak a full coherent and meaningful sentence. he was obviously trying to talk her out of it.

    6. and now for the biggest question, why was he filming? well, no one really knows. but I second my opinion with those who say that he was filming the new house they just got, and saw her there so he just kept on filming.

    of course, I am in no position to judge or draw conclusions, I just pointed a few obvious points that could be seen if the video is watched closely with an objective perspective without blaming one or the other.

    let’s just hope this case gets the adequate investigation.

    but for the poor girl’s sake, stop analyzing and concluding things that you don’t even know!

  17. So you are so close to the couple, their families, and investigation sources to the point you are in a position to state with certainty he was mistreating her and infected her with a sexual disease? You’re either so delusional so as to take your own personal case or that of someone close to you as a generality, which could be understandable to some extent, or worse than that you’re a spreader of baseless calumnies and lies.

    Have you even gotten your head out of your ostrich hole to notice that not one, not a single member of her family, close or far, not one of her many friends and acquaintances ever stood up to denounce a supposed case of mistreatment that drove her to commit suicide? But no, you want the world to take your wishful thinking as a reality instead of considering the facts.

    There is a reason why Amina’s family is focusing on the one and only cheap angle from where they can attempt putting the blame on the innocent husband although his infection with HPV wasn’t even a secret to Amina even before they got married. He got her vaccinated before any sexual contact as her family even knows and the very fact they are aware of the husband’s disease just a few months into that short marriage further proves it. Another fact for you is that the blood tests on her, done the day she died came back negative as investigation sources have reported or else the family would have already published those results through their lawyer in order to silence the growing rumors of her mental instability caused by a sexually abusing father. And by the way, if HPV was an issue for her, which it wasn’t, then why knowingly marry him in the first place? I’ll tell you why; simply because she loved him and because this virus isn’t even an issue for most of the world population that carries it without any symptoms.

    Lastly about the filming, it is important to consider the context of the event before speaking as you have the nasty habit of doing. All over the media, it was established that he was filming the back of the appt that was under work until he saw her standing at the balcony’s edge. As common sense tells you and as already pointed by others in their comments, you never rush towards someone in such a situation but try to reason. However it all went very fast and she left him no chance and did what she wanted to do. To keep on recording and at the same time trying to reason (something you’re ignoring) was the best thing to do because not only was he trying to save her as any emergency team would have done ie through negotiations but he was also this way safeguarding himself and the future of his own children and other people depending on him, by blocking the way to any false accusation the likes of those people like you are spreading.

    Finally regarding the so called late arrival of the ambulance that would have saved her instead had it arrived earlier, this is disproven by the eyewitnesses and the very person who was performing first aid on her, the owner of the pharmacy nearby who confirmed her death and changing face color just 3 min following her fall.

خبر عاجل